Game #51: Sabathia Comes Back to Haunt Tribe in Yanks 10-5 Win

C.C. Sabathia’s first 7 and a half seasons were spent hearing cheers from fans at Progressive Field, as he helped the Indians do their best to win games. Saturday night for the first time in his career, he was back in Cleveland in another uniform, the uniform of the New York Yankees.
Sabathia got some applause, but no matter how the crowd reacted, it really didn’t matter, as the Yankee offense did more than enough for him against Fausto Carmona to earn his 5th win of the season as the Yanks beat the Indians 10-5. C.C. went 7 innings, allowing three runs on five hits, walking three and striking out eight.
Carmona was pretty awful. He threw four innings, and never showed much, allowing 7 runs, four earned, on 8 hits, walking two and striking out two. He was supposed to be the number two man in the Tribe rotation, but has only one win in his last 8 outings, and falls to 2-5 on the season.
New York put up a pair in the second on two long homers that began their hit parade. The first homer was from Jorge Posada, the second a bomb from Nick Swisher that gave the team the 2-0 lead. The undoing of Carmona was the 4th, as he allowed nine Yankees to the plate as Derek Jeter, Johnny Damon and Robinson Cano all got RBI hits to make it a 7-0 lead.
After not putting up a hit in the first four innigs, the Tribe finally got on the board with two runs in the 5th. Ryan Garko and Jamey Carroll each had RBI hits to make it a 7-2 game. New York though answered right back, as Damon hit a ground out that scored Brett Gardner to make it 8-2.
A Grady Sizemore homer made it 8-3, and then the teams traded two runs each in the 9th, with the Tribe runs coming from a Shin-Soo Choo homer and Ben Francisco double to close the scoring at 10-5.
The bright spot for the Indians was the relief throwing of Tomo Ohka, who was able to save the bullpen by throwing five innings, allowing three runs on five hits with a walk and three strikeouts.
The team has lost two in a row after their four-game win streak. Sunday now at 21-30 they will put out Carl Pavano (5-4, 5.50) vs Phil Hughes at 12:40 p.m.







Matt has covered Major League Baseball and the "other two" Pro teams in Cleveland since 1994. He has been on the beat of the Indians in full-time mode since 1996, working for various raido and print networks around the country.